An Open Letter to My Reformed Brothers and Sisters
Posted by Doug McHone on 27 Dec 2004 at 06:21 am | Tagged as: Spiritual Growth
I have seen numerous examples of people abusing others in various forums due to their difference (or lack) of theological reasoning. Sadly, many of these people claim reformed doctrine as their own. Why is this? Have we discovered some truth that others just are unwilling to grasp? Have we found the true, exclusionary way to realize salvation? Are we now a step above other Christians? Has the realization that God chose us and set us apart in Him gone to our heads in such a way that we now have license to spiritually abuse those who haven’t come to similar conclusions? If you feel this is so, I have a message for you.
To be one of the elect taught in the Bible, you don’t need to be reformed. Believing in reformed traditions doesn’t ensure that you are of the elect. Is the theology of the reformation sound? Quite so! The truths I have labored to accept have brought peace to my heart the way no teaching has been able to do. My Bible has come alive to me once I placed God at the center and moved myself to my rightful place in my heart. I cherish the realization that I was set apart since before the forming of the world to be guiltless in the sight of God, but don’t look upon this truth as a reason to be abusive to those who disagree with me.
The first petal of the tulip should remind all who adhere to this doctrine that they are no better than anyone else. We did not find God, for He was never lost and even if He was, we weren’t looking for Him. Before our eyes were opened to the wonder and majesty that is our treasure, we wanted nothing to do with a God that had the audacity to make any claim on our self-worship. Through His word and by His spirit, we have discovered a truth that many (even many of those set apart) reject, but that is all. Even as some claim to have sole propriety over their decisions in life, the doctrine of original sin is one that is common to all. What gives us the right to proclaim someone a sinner or an outcast just because they don’t embrace the same theological structure?
God spoke and brought the universe to being. Just because an evolutionist denies this, does this mean that they do not exist? Adam spoke for us by choosing to find knowledge apart from the will of God. If someone denies this, does this mean that they are not infected with the same sin as you and I? God decided that I would be set apart as His. Was this not true before I was told about this?
Do you remember the discussion between Jesus and the Sadducees? They tested Jesus with the question of marital status after the resurrection and He corrected them.
Matthew 22:23-33
The same day the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection, came to Him and asked Him, saying: “Teacher, Moses said that if a man dies, having no children, his brother shall marry his wife and raise up offspring for his brother. Now there were with us seven brothers. The first died after he had married, and having no offspring, left his wife to his brother. Likewise the second also, and the third, even to the seventh. Last of all the woman died also. Therefore, in the resurrection, whose wife of the seven will she be? For they all had her.”Jesus answered and said to them, “You are mistaken, not knowing the Scriptures nor the power of God. For in the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are like angels of God in heaven. But concerning the resurrection of the dead, have you not read what was spoken to you by God, saying, “I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’? God is not the God of the dead, but of the living.” And when the multitudes heard this, they were astonished at His teaching.
The multitudes would not have been astonished had Jesus not understood the flawed teaching of the Sadducees. Doesn’t this mean that we have a responsibility to obtain some measure of understanding of things we don’t agree with, if for no reason than to be able to rebut what others claim? And Jesus answered with truth, not with malice. We all could learn from that passage as we discuss matters with those who we would like to bring to our way of thinking. All I ask is that we all consider the way Jesus handled the matter of differing doctrines. Jesus approached the matter with love and truth.
When reformed doctrine was introduced to me, it was done with love. A portion of this can be attributed to my own willingness to research the things I was told in my own Bible, but the fact remains that I was raised with a cocktail of doctrines that conflicted with each other, and most of these doctrines disagree with the reformed values. Thus, I hotly rejected what I was told until scripture convicted me. Had I been treated as some are treated in forums on the internet and other mediums I have seen, I never would have considered researching what was told to me.
Did you catch that last line? It was the Godly love of two men I am proud to call brothers that encouraged me to look into a doctrine that placed the emphasis on God and not myself. In examples I have seen recently, there is often no love expressed by reformed people. Rather we take our doctrine to excuse an attitude of superiority, as if by fighting this battle for the Lord brings glory to His name. Election should humble us, not allow us to raise our self-worth over another person, whether they are a believer in any fashion or not. Moving the center of the universe is a difficult thing for anyone to do. Let us not make it any harder.
We all are on a search. Some of us realize it, some don’t. Still they are looking.
The key to your observations is you never did the research.
Imagine someone telling you they owned the sharpest sword in the world. If you didn’t believe them, they would slap you. What? Why not stab you with it.
The word is the sharpest. The only way we get the full impact is to ready, study, think about it.
The word carries a message simple enough that children can sing “Jesus Loves Me” and get the story.
Yet, others have spent their whole lives reading and there are still questions to be answered.
Read. Ponder and Pray. It works.
Cheers.
FM
The key to your observations is you never did the research.
I believe I have been doing some research regarding matters such as this. Consider the following:
How is belittling others who are not like-minded a good example of this passage? If we are the body of Christ, how well are we representing Him? How loving is our message? What fruits are we displaying?
Could you clarify what you are getting at please?
I think your post makes a great point. Two actually, as I see it. My own personal beliefs are of a less “mainstream” theology. What
amazessaddens me is how many people reject truth because it is contrary to what they have known.You can share the scriptures with them and no matter how many you have to demonstrate God’s will, they will find 1 passage, twist it, and claim it as reproof. Usually it is one of Paul’s writings and most times it is from a translation that is more of an “easy read”. Reminds me of 2 Peter 3:15-16Bear in mind that our Lord’s patience means salvation, just as our dear brother Paul also wrote you with the wisdom that God gave him. He writes the same way in all his letters, speaking in them of these matters. His letters contain some things that are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, as they do the other Scriptures, to their own destruction.
It seems to me that there is an undesireable result of twisting Scripture. Or of those teaching that all or parts of the law do not exist today. You are teaching people to sin, for sin is transgression of the law. And does the Bible say anything about this?
Mark 9:42
However, there are many in every denomination, even those basing teaching solely on the Scriptures, that love their religion and/or correct doctrine more than the God it is about! They make their own religion an idol.
There is a balance to be held. Ther are also many examples up bold rebuke(Elijah v. baal prophets, John the Baptist, Stephen, Jesus all called the Pharisees either hypocrites, brood of vipers or stiff-necked, or think of Jesus and the money changers) They were examples of being bold when boldness was needed… so that none should be lost. That’s the love part of it all.
Matt. 10:16
I have posted some on making sure when we explain our theology, we give examples of how it blesses us and those we minister to. I think the point always has to be helping people worship and grow spiritually. I really do not like arguements about ideas. Ideas are the point. Spiritual growth and discipleship is the point.
From a brother who has a different theological stance in some areas from yourself I offer this: Great Post, Brother. Amen.
Doug - For an interesting experience, say something bad about the emerging church and watch what happens. I think you will find that there are other groups that can be as uncharitable and just plain mean as Calvinists.
But I echo what others have said. Good job on this post.
Your Open Letter is “spot on” as they say in England. (I don’t know why they say it in England, I’ve never been there, but I have seen Monty Python.)
I don’t understand why those who claim to be the most Biblical (Reformed)miss the fact that 1 Cor 13 teaches clearly that love (true love, actions, not assertions) trumps everything religious. Reformed folks seem loathe to consider that bad theology with love is more pleasing to God than Berkhof without love. (Full disclosure: I am a former PCA pastor).Also, Jesus never gave those with moral failures a hard time. (Look it up!)He reserved his wrath for religious leaders.
Keep on keeping on. Jesus appreciates love. It is the mark of the true church (Biblical definition). Word, sacrament and discipline are the human tradition definition. Let’s stick with Jesus, shall we?
Sorry about the multiple posts. I ain’t learned to operate this here newfangled typewriter too durn good.
CS Lewis wrote “… the only cure is too keep the
clean sea breeze of the times blowing through our
heads.” In my opinion this means to read OLD BOOKS.
When I read the works of William Law I realize how
much I have really been missing when I warm a pew in
church; hearing the same message for the 10th time.
When you think of The Fall as a demotion (read Gen 3
carefully); I didn’t fall — scraping my knee, God
changed my state from a perfect creature — to our
current state. This is a metaphysical state change.
Since only God can get us here — only God can
provide the solution! To add to the problem God
added disorder to the state of nature so man would
have to work for his food.